George Washington Papers

From George Washington to John Carey, 30 December 1796

To John Carey

Philadelphia 30th Decr 1796

Sir,

I have received your letters of the 8th and 9th of September and first of October.1

I am much indebted to you for the interest you feel, to have the imposition that has been attempted upon the public, detected. With great truth you pronounced it such.2 I shall leave something on this subject,3 to be used when I shall be permitted to enjoy peace & repose.4

In the mean while I pray you to accept of my thanks for your present, and believe me to be Sir, Your obliged Hble Servt

Go: Washington

ALS (letterpress copy), DLC:GW; Df, in James McHenry’s writing, MiU-C: McHenry Papers; Df, in James McHenry’s and Timothy Pickering’s writing, MiU-C: McHenry Papers; LB, DLC:GW. GW enclosed this letter with his to John Trumbull of 13 Jan. 1797 (see n.2 to that document). McHenry’s undated draft appears to have served as the basis for the recipient’s copy, as the ALS contains similar wording.

The other draft in McHenry’s and Pickering’s writing, which contains strikeouts, interlineations, and significant differences from the letterpress copy, reads: “Your letters of the 8 & 9 Sept. & 1 of Octer have been reced.

“Accept of my thanks for the interest you have taken, to have the forgery to which my name has been affixed placed in a clear point of view. The letters in question bearing the title of ‘Epistles Domestic, Confidential & Official, from General Washington,’ … were not written by me; nor did I ever see or hear of them until they issued from a press in New York at an early period of the American war, for purposes very well understood by my country men and which rendered it unnecessary at that time for me to have declared them a forgery.

“Nor did I loose a particle of my baggage during the whole course of the war. As however the actors of that day to whom these circumstances were known must, like myself, soon disappear from the stage; I have thought it a duty which I owed to truth and to the rising generation to state these facts to the printer of the forged letters and to request him to have them made public. I inclose you a copy of what I have written to him.

“I presume they ought to be with held for the present. As to the other matters your own judgement—aided with the advice of the American minister in London [Rufus King] will be quite adequate.”

1No letter from Carey to GW of 9 Sept. has been found. Carey alluded to it when he wrote GW on 1 Oct., but he may have misstated the date of the letter (see Carey to GW, 1 Oct., and n.1).

2Carey had published a piece denouncing the 1796 republication of Revolutionary War-era letters that had been falsely attributed to GW (see Carey to GW, 1 Oct., and n.1 to that document).

3At this point on his draft, McHenry added “with one of my friends.”

4GW later wrote a formal statement refuting the forgeries and asked that it be deposited in the State Department as a testimony for posterity (see GW to Pickering, 3 March 1797).

Index Entries